Oracle Plays Catch up with PeopleSoft
Written by John J. Xenakis for
CFO.com,
Apr 11, 2001.
Oracle's upgraded ERP system includes an HR component that's a strong
competitor to PeopleSoft's.
Last year, when Oracle Corp. overhauled its enterprise resource
planning software with Release 11i, it renamed the system the E-
Business Suite to emphasize the degree to which the Web is now
incorporated into the system.
But more important, the company revamped its Human Resources
Management System (HRMS) module, and it's worthwhile to ask whether
Oracle has finally caught up to PeopleSoft, the ERP industry's
long-time leader in human resources systems.
Both systems have similar features, but they differ widely on their
marketing and pricing policies for the two products.
Like many enterprise products, both Oracle HRMS 11i and PeopleSoft
HRMS 8.0 are different from earlier versions. The client/server
technology has been abandoned, and all functions are accessible
through Web browsers. New functions, such as those that empower
employees to design their benefits package online or automate the
selection of candidates for new positions, are available because of
the Web technology.
In fact, Oracle has performed studies of its customers that indicate
that using Oracle HRMS 11i can save HR costs of 25 percent per
employee with the new functionality, and there's every reason to
believe that similar savings would be achieved with PeopleSoft HRMS
8.0.
Oracle HRMS has made an enormous difference to Kelly Staff Leasing,
according to the general manager, Mike Butler. "Handling payroll and
benefit functions was formerly very paper intensive," he says. "In
the past, we received payroll input in several different ways --
faxed time cards, E-mailed spreadsheets, or calls to our computer from
a modem line. These are being streamlined so that all the input comes
in through a Web browser."
Although the payroll area was the one having the biggest impact,
according to Butler, the benefits area also changed for the Troy,
Mich., based temp agency and HR outsourcing firm.
"One of our key deliverables to our client is offering a comprehensive
suite of benefits for their employees," he says. "With Oracle's
advanced benefits module, employees can view their benefits, get live
updates, and track new benefits interactively."
According to Butler, a great strength of 11i is its flexibility in
adding or changing entire benefit programs, something that he has to
do frequently because he has to support multiple corporate clients. In
fact, he compares his situation to that of a company that has been
formed from a number of mergers and acquisitions.
"It's not uncommon to see large companies that have many different
systems that have to be integrated -- with different HR rules,
benefits and vacation policies, and with different tax treatments in
different statements. It's amazing how many different rules you have
to administer, and this software can handle it."
In fact, integration within the Oracle ERP suite itself is one of the
major strong points of the products, according to Jenni Lehman, an
analyst at Stamford, Conn., based Gartner Inc.
"I give Oracle high scores in integrating HR types of data throughout
the enterprise, not just in the HR department," says Lehman. "Every
one of the vendors supports the HR department but every department has
an HR element, and Oracle is much more aware of that, supporting that
much more aggressively than the other vendors. And it goes will with
their single application integration story: Oracle says that you
should buy from just one vendor."
This single application message is highly engrained in Oracle,
especially since it's unique among ERP vendors in that it also
supplies the database software in addition to the ERP software.
"All our products can be purchased modularly," says Tony Cavanagh,
Oracle's director for E-Business Suite marketing. "But our pitch is
that it's better to truly wage a war on complexity, and to avoid
managing multiple release dates and upgrades, and to get better
functionality and integration in one suite, rather than trying to
stitch different products together."
This is different from PeopleSoft's strategy, which frequently
involves HRMS-only sales. "It's no secret that [other vendors] tend to
bundle HRMS in with their larger ERP package offering, whether the
organization gets HRMS whether they want it or not," says Julie
Thomas, director of HRMS marketing. "PeopleSoft went to market as an
HRMS vendor, so we've had a different strategy."
The different strategy focuses resources particularly on HRMS, and it
shows, according to Gartner's Lehman.
"All of the products do the core functionality well, but PeopleSoft is
still the one to beat," she says. According to Lehman, the overall
design and flow of the PeopleSoft product, as well as the designs of
the individual screens, are more intuitive and easy to use and provide
easier collaboration among users than in the Oracle product. "Oracle
has a great product, and they've done really well adding
functionality, but they're still focused on the nuts and bolts. I
still give PeopleSoft the edge in vision for how to manage human
capital."
"We're becoming much more bottom line oriented and [PeopleSoft HRMS]
is the best solution," says Michael Head, exec VP for human resources
from Regions Financial Corp., a Birmingham, Alabama, banking firm. "It
gives us more robust and seamless platform for management reporting,
and more cost-effective controls."
Head is rolling out PeopleSoft HRMS to 110 managers heading up an
organization of 17,000 employees. "We have a very decentralized
management structure. We'll be rolling out time and labor systems
throughout the company. The system will avoid performance reviews not
being done, and handle staffing issues."
Head has outsourced his payroll and HR, and uses PeopleSoft through
an application service provider, Oasis Software LLC of Brentwood,
Tenn. PeopleSoft's license was slightly less than $400,000.
He decided on an ASP solution, paying Oasis $350 per month for each
manager, a price which includes hosting the software and outsourcing
all IT and payroll functions. Because of staff savings and
infrastructure savings, Head expects the system to pay for itself in
less than two years.
This highlights some of the major marketing and pricing differences
between Oracle and PeopleSoft that the new releases have brought
about.
The Internet has dramatically changed the functionality of both the
Oracle and PeopleSoft HRMS software, but when Oracle's changes to its
marketing and pricing have been more dramatic. The company is now
using the Internet as a distribution channel for all its enterprise
software. Anyone can go to Oracle's Web site and purchase as many
licenses as desired for each of the HRMS modules.
There are seven Oracle HRMS modules in all: human resources, payroll,
time management, advanced benefits, training and administration, self-
service HR, and HR intelligence. Perpetual license prices range from
$25 to $60 per module per user. The site gives prices for two or three
year licenses as well. In keeping with Oracle's singlE-vendor message,
the site also provides ASP prices, with Oracle acting as the hosting
company.
It's hard to overstate what a big change this is. For years, the major
ERP software players have refused to divulge software prices publicly,
and used what they called "value pricing," which meant they charged
the customer as much as they could get.
Oracle now believes that value pricing has had a negative effect on
the company, according to Cavanagh. "If there's no rigidity in
pricing, and there are lots of discounts, then you get a lot of ups
and downs in revenues, just as the best time to buy a car is the last
Sunday of the month," he says. "Larry [Ellison] reviewed the
significant discounts and said it had to stop. We had to get better
control over pricing in order to build significant business over the
Web. So this is the result of our own E-business transformation."
PeopleSoft has not reached the same conclusion and will continue
value pricing, according to HRMS marketing director Thomas.
"If we thought customers were pushing us to list prices on our Web
site, I think PeopleSoft would do that," she says. "But buying
software is complex, and sales cycles can be one month to six months
or longer. Why not let customers rely on a salesperson to give them
the information they need?"
(This is a modified version of an article that originally
appeared on
Apr 11, 2001
on
CFO.com
at
this location.
)
|